News
Is Y&R About To Recast Katherine Chancellor's son, Tucker McCall?

91
I would love to have Nichols back. I doubt he would return considering he was sorely underused when he was there.
Tucker’s in England having started a new company. Would seem strange to just leave it all behind. I don’t know that Katherine would leave him Chancellor. What about Murphy? I know he can’t run it, but she could leave it to him. I thought they were a bit estraged before he left.
I’m almost certain that it will be Cane in order to cause friction between him and Jill.
UGH!!!!!
Not really a big fan of the character. Not invested. Soooooo many new faces/recasts in G City. But if it means tons of Kay/Jill story, then I’m all for it.
Just for the heck of it…. why not…. 1/2 to Jill and 1/2 to Nikki?
Get Nikki out from under the “Newman” Men… honestly…..
course, i’ve heard it said before… women always cat fighting…. but, this would give Nikki a whole new lease on life.
I don’t know… I was more thinking about what to do with Nikki…
she’s evenmoreso… A Pivotal character… what with… Katherine, Phylllis… and Ashley gone.
I do think Katherine’s death needs to be an umbrella story for all the vets and not only the business aspect but personal. Leaving Nikki some property with millions and Nikki refurbishes the building…it was once where the “The Colonnade” once stood and she reopens the fining dining establishment, Gina is administrator of dining…close the ugly “On the Blvd”! U are right Nikki is so pivotal for character with all departing. The mansion should be Jill has her half, Katherine leaves her half to Nina & Mac…and the saga continues Jill vs Nina…think about some of the cat fights Jess… Read more »
I definately agree about giving Nina more air time… she’s central as well.
Jess and Tricia going at it would lend itself credibility… as they’re known for it.
Nichols would be cool, but they should do a twist to it, and have it turn out Paul Williams is really Catherine’s son, Since Doug Davidson was like a son to Jeanne anyways, and would give him more airtime.
Wow, can’t believe they aren’t planning on asking Nichols back! He is one of the finest actors in Daytime (of all time). Their loss…and ours:(
Ditto…. kind of a slap in the face, if they don’t ask him…. SN may not see it that way… but… he’s TALENT… and they wasted him, like SOOOO MANY others.
Patrick I was under the impression that JFP did not like him that’s the reason his contract was not renewed.
It will be a friend of JFP so take it from there. Or she could always put aging stage makeup on Steve Burton and he could do dual roles! And if you think I am kidding I am not if she thought she could do it she would the nails in the coffin are almost complete.
The nails in the coffin of the once great soap Y&R she has doubled down on what MAB started.
I hope there is re-cast because he was no fan fav on Y&R. I loved the Tucker played by William Russ, he was outgoing, optimistic, romantic, and seemed like a corporate raider. I still smile when I remember Tucker bring Jill breakfast in bed and surprising her with red stilettos and diamond earrings. The re-cast with SN making Tucker into this brooding spoiled old man who took delight in being nasty to woman he had sex with was a huge turn -off. The rock and roll hippie who had sex with groupies and calling each other by groupie names- just… Read more »
So full of crap. nichols is definately a fan favorite.
Fan favorite yes but not on YR he displayed no real qualities for the character, please recast if we need this character.
Harlee, that’s your opinion. I’ve been watching Y&R for over 35 years and I thought SN was a great addition! I thought his scenes with JC were always stellar. He brought a uniqueness and layers to Tucker. He is the one that made me stop and take notice of Tucker. I can’t speak for everyone, but from what I’m seeing online his portrayal of Tucker was far more popular with Y&R viewers than you think.
Yes this my opinion, I been watching as you a longtime viewer for 40 years and I just didn’t see the layers but again it goes back to this period of the writing and that is what I didn’t enjoy. Jeanne was always stellar regardless and you’re correct. Some scenes were very good wJeanne you didn’t find SN performances as stellar….good at times yes according who he was doing a scene with and other times just horrible. I think it’s a mixed bag there are plenty that would agree with you but there are plenty that would agree that if… Read more »
Once again, it’s all about Jill. Judging an actor on whether or not Jill gets some loving is absurd. The character of Tucker is not defined by Jill. The actors don’t get to write their own storylines. The actor is not defined by Jill and who Jill sleeps with or who she looks good with. As far as SN being popular with Y&R viewers, check the boards. It’s only the same one who runs from one point to the other and complains about how Jill was treated that seems to have the biggest complaints.
I think SN is a great actor, but I didn’t like him as Tucker. I liked the original guy who played Tucker and ticked off that they didn’t keep him.
Fan group polls mean nothing. I love Daniel Goddard, but I don’t think most viewers would consider him the best actor on Y&R. Regardless he wins the weekly best actor contest/poll all the time & has for years. At least his fans are mostly Y&R viewers. The SN/Tucker polls/thread get many of it’s votes/support from Days and/or GH viewers who don’t even watch Y&R, And even then it’s just not that many. Tucker may not be defined by Jill, but Katherine was (in part) as was Jill defined (in part) by Katherine. They were developed together since day 1 and… Read more »
Liza, I didn’t see any mention of fan polls in the comment you’re responding to, but yes, they do mean something. They show the popularity of the actor in the role. I think Little Kittens was talking about reading actual postings on message boards. Clearly, if you read them you will see that, one, SN was very popular as Tucker, and two, those posters that are posting about him do watch, otherwise they wouldn’t have detailed knowledge of Tucker’s past storyline. Funny, being that SN is currently not on contract with Y&R, GH, or Days (that we know of) you… Read more »
I’m not talking about polls. If you actually read the boards before posting, you’d know. No one else defines the character of Tucker solely by his association to Jill or by Katherine. The show is not all about Jill or Katherine. It’s an ensemble. Your reasoning suggests that if Tucker had been on the show for multiple years, he would then be acceptable. Since that is not the case, by your reasoning, a recast wouldn’t be acceptable either. Apparently, you are going to have to find a different way to bash the actor, since that is your motivating factor.
Perfect list and so appropriate of the last 40 years of Katherine’s connections but 80% is “All About Jill”…Jill now is playing the Anne Baxter role which it should be because the use of this long history opens the floodgate of story for Jill alone….sigh…
Bring back her son Brock. He should get the money.
Me! I’d love to be a Tucker recast!
I would love to see Tom Eplin back on daytime– he could play the new Tucker, does anyone know if he is one JFP friends or one of her enemies? But if not him someone who used to be on AW that I haven’t seen in ages would be cool. JFP must of made some friends on that show that she could now import onto this one. This SL could be good if they have all the Chancellor’s back- Brock, his daughter Mac, Phillip and Chance– with Devon and Tucker thrown in, all competing with Jill for their share of… Read more »
Wow! GOOD. idea! Tom Eplin was Amazing on Another World.
That would be something that would start me watching again.
I won’t be happy unless Tucker is played by Nichols. He is a great actor and bringing is anyone else is a bad idea. He even had a physical resemblance to Jeanne Cooper and Devon.I have watched Nichols play Patch on Days and Tucker on Y&R he is such a good actor that I easily accepted him in both roles.
bring tom eplin ex jake another world. he would be really good as tucker. oh robert kelker kelly too. why not. both are very good actors. jill pharren phelps needs to be fired. i cant stand this woman. she is a soap killer. young and the restless will be on life support sooner than later. she always brings her friends teachers pet on the young and the restless and creates roles for her friends. steve burtons new role is boring. cannot even act. a friend also to jill pharren phelps. lol.
If it is going to be an ex AW person it will be Kale Browne/Michael Hudson he was on the set just a few months ago and he is the right age and he is a FOJ! I happen to like KB so I do not care the only problem I have with them bringing the character back is I wished it will be short term and take Devon with you. RKK is definitely to young for the role and he is basically retired and flying now. As for JFP my husband would not permit me to go to the… Read more »
Knowing JFP it will be another cast member of Hollywood Heights like Grayson McCouch or Carlos Ponce. Someone they can get cheaper than Nichols.
My picks would be:
– Grayson McCouch
– Leigh J McCloskey
– Tom Eplin
– Laurence Lau
– Timothy Gibbs
– Gordon Thompson
All good choices
Leigh J McCloskey is already present on YR as Nikki’s doctor which original was seeing Ashley originally years ago….hmmmm we need Brenda back like yesterday if we can’t have Eileen…please YR!
Stefan Cassadine to GH. Stat.
What about Brock? If the original is not available, then a recast. I think Laurance Lau would be a fabulous choice to play Brock. It would be an easy transition since Brock hasn’t been seen regularly. I just can’t see her leaving Chancellor Industries to just recently found Cane or grandson. Her husband has no corporate skills – he can inherit enough money to ensure a comfortable last years of retirement.
NO BROCK RECAST!!!!! FIRE JILL FARREN PHELPS, I loath the Bitch!
I loathe her too. She’s a power-wielding, destructive, ineffective hack who’s now using Jeanne Cooper’s death to soften her own tarnished image and deflect criticism of her total lack of talent and leadership. How she’s lasted sooooo long in this business is a mystery.
rickie i agree with you. jill pharren phelps is a bitch. she needs to get fired now and go away. she only likes her favroites like steve burton and her other teachers pet friends. jill is a soap killer.
No recast on Brock!…the original would probably be delighted to return FT…has major history wJill…much more logical compare to T-u-c-k-e-r…it’s no brain who the audience does know that has a deep connection to YR canvas is Brock…opening the door for Mac to return, making way for Chance to return (recast)…and goes on…Tucker has Devon, this family tree branch is short compared to Brock & Jill’s family tree ihas many branches spreading and deep connections to Katherine….
I wish Stephen Nichols comes back to GH i miss him .
Praying for the return of Stephen Nichols as well to the role of Stefan Cassadine! Laura needs the only man who truly cherished,loved & encouraged her & that was Stefan! Old man Luke & whiny Scott have got to go! Francis & Nichols chemistry is fantastic onscreen,he was the one man that finally tore L&L apart never to be the same again! Stefan & Laura were my favorite couple on GH & again when he played Tucker & she was Genieve on Y&R. It’s time for them to have the real romance they should of had many years ago. I… Read more »
I was never a fan of character of Tucker played by either actor. I think it was the story on how it was conceived in the beginning. Now, with the death of Katherine looming and you can’t undo all this mess now it seems almost a necessity to have Tucker back for story with Katherine dying. If they can recast Tucker then they can bring back Brock at the same time, Brock has equal shares of CI. Let it be Brock vs Tucker.
My next question is Phillip & Chance are the REAL Chancellor why not have those two back instead of Tucker?
I think Susan Flannery should be figured into this whole thing— there arent too many grand dame’s of daytime left and she could fill these shoes if she has had enough of retirement!
They should bright back the original Tucker……Stephen Nichols
But he’s not the original “Tucker”
Willam Russ was the original.
Brock will never be interested in running his mother’s company.
I think it will fall to Cane – which will ultimately lead to conflict with Lily and Jill….and Tucker.
I do wish he was going to be played by Stephen Nichols again tho.
It will be strange to have a new actor assume an established role and no prior relationship to any of the actors/characters.
Not impossible – but a challenge.
Not if Y&R doesn’t want the type of Tucker that was established. As someone on twitter stated “Who wants a bitter rich septuagenarian with abandonment and commitment and sluttishness issues. NO ONE.” I hoping the new face also means a new personality, and what better time to become a completely new man than at the death of the bio-mom he obsessed about for ages. If Y&R want to bring back the audience that tunes in for the funeral they are going to want a character they like. SN was only in the role for 3 years, on Y&R that’s a… Read more »
First off, SN is in his early 60s. Just clarifying that.
Second, I think you’re confusing or rather blurring some lines here. Tucker is a character that is scripted – not a real person – therefore his personality is scripted by the writers. SN’s personality is not Tucker’s and Tucker’s is not SN’s. Whether Tucker has a new face or is played by SN, the writing will be the same. SN has played the role since its inception, except for the first month. He has all of Tucker’s history with Katherine.
“Not if Y&R doesn’t want the type of Tucker that was established. As someone on twitter stated “Who wants a bitter rich septuagenarian with abandonment and commitment and sluttishness issues. NO ONE.”
Uhhh… you said it, under one of your many aliases.
The twitter quote is from @MarkHsoap, a regular #YR tweeter. That’s not me, but obviously you are going to believe what you want so if you want to give me credit fine. LOL
LOLOL… doesn’t matter. Tucker is not being recast, so I guess all this ‘banter’ doesn’t matter. LOLOL…..
P.S. Did you get permission from this Mark guy to repost his info and tweets? I mean, I know Twitter isn’t exactly private, but still. I don’t think I would want anyone helping themselves to my stuff and using it for their agendas. Just a thought.
Stephen Nichols should be asked back! It’s a no-brainer! He has three years of scenes encompassing every emotion with Jeanne Cooper, all which could be used in flashbacks! Seeing a recast play the part of the grieving son will ring hollow with viewers, who will expect to see Nichols. It would be a disservice to the storyline to cast an actor that hadn’t worked with Jeanne!! The only one who could do the part justice is the one who had the most scenes with Jeanne in the role. Stephen and Jeanne worked so well together!! I hope he is asked… Read more »
Yes!! That is brilliance Kat!! The flashbacks that would lead to more and hopefully better storylines are right there waiting to carry Y&R into Years of rich,far reaching stories for everyone!!
Bradley Cole ex Guiding Light worked with JFP for a little while on GH, he could be an excellent Tucker.
Another good choice
Stephen was brilliant as Tucker and I loved him during the tribute to Jeanne episode. However, if they chose to recast, I would be welcoming it, but only if the recast was equal to and/or better than Mr. Nichols!
Of course… I would love to see Stephen Nichols on any soap… GH first and then either YR or DOOL. He’s fabuloous!!! Don’t think it will be Y&R though…
I can’t say this surprises me at all. It makes story sense to bring back Kay’s children — both of them. Especially Tucker from a business perspective, and let’s not forget a funeral coming. My thoughts are that JFP and SN don’t adore each other, so one of them very likely doesn’t want tot work with the other, or maybe both. So, either one wants the role to go to SN and one doesn’t, or they both mutually agree that they’re happy not to work with each other. Either way, it’s not surprising to me at all, and it’s really… Read more »
OMG bring him back. Not someone else, PLEASE! If you have to bring someone in could it be George Clooney!
Brock is her son too! If it is not the real Tucker Brock will do. I am sure you can make a story line for Brock. But if Tucker is gong to be a player and the real Tucker is not in the picture you will have to bring in some very handsome, loveable character.
I would prefer Stephen NIchols to any other Tucker but if this is determined to be a recast I would be shocked if it wasn’t Kale Brown.
Grayson McCouch is about 20 years too young. It would be awesome to have Tom Eplin back on soaps, but he is a bit too young as well. I’d suggest Kale Browne or David Forsyth. Both are Phelps faves, but that doesn’t bother me here, since both are good solid actors, and either would have chemistry with Jess Walton and other cast members. I am also waiting for the reveal that Cane is actually Tucker’s son. This was strongly hinted at before Genie Francis and Nichols were axed, so the story couldn’t proceed. But with a recast the story could… Read more »
Robert Newman aka Guiding Light’s Josh Lewis.
I’m thinking Kale Brown will get the job. She brought him over to OLTL as Sam Rappaport and made him s HUGE part of that show.
Sorry but I could never watch another friend of Jill
Just as long as it’s not Devon. I can’t stand his punk self.
I like Robert Newman as Tucker or even John Wesley Shipp (ATWT, GL)
I would like them to bring back Stephen Nichols. He’s Tucker and will always be Tucker in my eyes.
Stephen Nichols needs to return in order for the storyline to work. I don’t understand
Why they let him go and put all those kids that have no storyline and that are so
Boring!!!! I’ve watched Y&R for 40 years, we need our vets back on with a new
storyline, it’s gotten where its same storyline just repeated!!!! Wake up and get this
Soap back where it needs to be!!!!! Use our Vets don’t waste them, cause they are
All great!
Stephen Nichols is NOT a Y&R vet. He was on for 3 years- the MAB years- the lowest viewed years in Y&R’s history. Many viewers who come back for Kay’s funeral will have never heard of Tucker.
I think the Y&R veteran actors are perfectly capable of making the story line work.
I second that no SN…his performances were lazy and uninspiring at best….too lackadaisical & no feeling is what I saw and this is why I couldn’t warm up to Tucker…maybe with the right actor & writing~~~possibly…hmmm
the writing was lazy the actor was superb. Now boring one note acting is Steve Burton as Dylan and Goddard as Cane
I just respectfully disagree on SN. Absolutely the writing was lazy and seen many big name stars make sugar out of shiz and turn it to gold we all could name a few…SN doesn’t fall in that category he brought nothing to the role at least on YR. I’m not saying SN couldn’t be good in the right character role but Tucker wasn’t one of them that shined.
Michael Park.
I agree with Gia, Michael Park would be great.. I am sick of JFP and her friends on the soap, also sick of The Chelsea show…sick of seeing her and hearing her laugh, maybe it’s time for me to turn off Y&R..
I love me some Michael Park, but he is not Tucker McCall material at all!
I want Nichols back. He was great. Loved him with ED as Ashley. Fabulous chemistry. I wish they could both return.
Why would they recast? Unless Nichols does not WANT to return (because, let’s face it, who would after being canned?), I see no reason to recast. Nichols is supremely talented and had great chemistry with cast mates (granted, most of whom he played with are no longer there). Also, unless they really intend to use Tucker, I’d rather not have the character on the canvas. Y&R has too many good characters being wasted these days and I wouldn’t like to see Tucker as the next casuality.
Stephen Nichols should Return. JFP however has proven to EXCLUSIVELY HIRE HER FRIENDS. i will not watch if its one of the FRIENDS OF JILL. I ALREADY CANNOT WATCH BURTON
Tom Eplin. And Jensen Buchanan in some way!!!
Count me in as NOT wanting a recast of Tucker McCall!! Stephen Nichols was perfect in the role! I’ve been watching ‘The Young’ for close to forty years and no – I wasn’t a fan of Stephen’s prior to his being on the show. Sure, I had seen soap mag covers of ‘Patch’ and such, but never saw his work. It’s a bit irritating to have to say that as if it it assumed that Tucker as a character could not possibly be well received on its own merit, but yes, he can and is by many I presume. Anyway,… Read more »
I want kay alden back as a principal writer of this show. Since her and bill bell left , the show became really boring. I do miss jack vs victor , dru vs phylis , nickki vs diane , jill vs kay . Not to mention about super couples she created. She knew how to pull it out. Bac ( david tom and ashely b, jollen thad and lindsey , raul and brittany etc.) All of them have good chemistry together. Today most of couples on this show are very boring , i can’t stand one of them.
SN COULD COME TO GH AND PLAY THE ROLE:
STEFAN CASSIDINE
OR KELLY MONACO FATHER
I think they should bring back the latest Tucker McCall. He is very handsome and there was great chemistry between him and Devon
General Hospital
OLTL Favorite Susan Batten to Guest-Star on General Hospital
Breaking News
49th Annual Daytime Emmy Awards Winners Circle (Photos)
News
Peter Bergman Signs 5-Year Deal with The Young and the Restless
-
General HospitalJune 17, 2022
General Hospital’s Rebecca Herbst Shuts Down Rumors and Speculation
-
Breaking NewsJune 24, 2022
Lamon Archey and Sal Stowers Exit Days of our Lives
-
General HospitalJune 20, 2022
General Hospital 15,000th Episode Milestone Promo
-
General HospitalJune 21, 2022
GH’s Finola Hughes, Marcus Coloma & Josh Swickard Talk On 15,000th Episode Milestone
-
NewsJune 25, 2022
Peter Bergman Signs 5-Year Deal with The Young and the Restless
-
Breaking NewsJune 25, 2022
49th Annual Daytime Emmy Awards Winners Circle (Photos)
-
Breaking NewsJune 25, 2022
49th Annual Daytime Emmy Awards: General Hospital, B&B’s John McCook and Y&R’s Mishael Morgan Take Top Honors
-
Breaking NewsJune 21, 2022
Michael Bolton to Perform New Song & During In Memoriam Segment at 49th Annual Daytime Emmys