Days Of Our Lives
Jen Lilley Reveals Shortened DAYS Return and Recast: “The Girl Coming Back as Theresa is a Brunette”
This week on Days of our Lives, several key returns come to Salem for Victor’s (the late John Aniston) memorial and the aftermath of the story arc, which includes Jen Lilley in the role of Theresa Donovan.
Lilley’s comeback begins on the Friday, September 1st episode of the Peacock streaming soap opera. The actress, who has become a major lead in Hallmark Channel and then Great American Family movies and other projects, played the role of DAYS mischievous Theresa from 2013-2016 and made a return visit to the soap in 2018.
However, in a newly-released video interview with Soaps.com’s Kristyn Burtt, Lilley shares the back-story of how she reached out to then Days of our Lives co-executive producer, Albert Alarr, expressing her interest to reprise the role of Theresa, so she could be included in Victor’s memorial episodes. Since Lilley loved working with John Aniston, she was hoping there would be some way to work things out to pave the way for her to be a part of it.
Jen shared that she made herself available for 3 to 4 weeks, but the soap said they had story planned for Theresa for 12. After a back and forth, she was led to believe they were putting 12 weeks of episodes into 3 to 4 weeks to accommodate Lilley’s availability, which she noted, “is so gracious.”
Later, when Jen wasn’t receiving the amount of scripts she thought she would be given, she felt something was up. That’s when she found out and realized, that DAYS had recast the role of Theresa with another actress to play out the longer run of episodes after confronting Alarr.

Photo: JPI
According to Lilley, she said, “Listen, you told me Theresa’s going to do X, Y and Z, and I haven’t gotten the scripts. I only have one more for Monday, and I have two weeks left (on set).” At that point, Alarr informed Jen that the remainder of the episodes would be in the hands of another actress.
Lilley shared on her recast: “The girl coming back as Theresa is a brunette, and when I was ready to come back, I was ready to cut my hair and dye it brown to play Theresa again. I said, ‘I’ll do whatever you guys need, I’m so grateful.”
The actress reports that while she was working at DAYS, the other actress was already at the set, but Jen had no idea that she was the Theresa recast. Lilley shared, “Albert said on the replacement, ‘She’s known for three weeks.'” That’s when, Lilley detailed they were going to put the other actress in a wig.
Finding herself in a very awkward situation, Lilley went to the actress and said, “I am so sorry. I just found out, that must be so awkward for you.” Jen also shared to her replacement, how brutal it was for her with GH fans when she was a recast as Maxie Jones.
In the end, Lilley expressed, on the time she received to come back to play Theresa: “I was still super grateful to go back for the two weeks and one day. I am happy that the story of Brady (Eric Martsolf) and Theresa can continue on.” Jen also noted that the door seems to be open for her to return as Theresa down the road.
So, what do you think about DAYS replacing Jen Lilley during upcoming episodes as Theresa? Who do you think will take on the role? Comment below.
I’m disgusted!!
Jen’s portrayal of Theresa was a favorite to watch at least for me.
This show is becoming more and more discombobulated.
I agree…Peacock is ruining the Days that I loved!!!
Peacock has nothing to do with it.
It’s not Peacock that was ruining Days it was Alan Alarrs doing that caused so many issues! Now that he is gone things will be so much better! Peacock has already renewed Days for another 2 years!!
Then FIRE Alan…Or Rather More Reduce To Mopping Floors And Cleaning The Restrooms…
I beg to differ with you. Peacock is doing a fantastic job.
Not Only That…It’s Quite Stupid That We Have To Go To Peacock And Pay To Watch The Show…I’ve Missed Almost 1 Years Of It Now Since The Last Episode Aired On NBC September 9Th/2022…
The choice was likely Peacock or cancellation. For some not willing or able to subscribe to Peacock, it might feel like cancellation anyway.
Peacock IS NBC! They are ruining Days, it would have been the same script, even if they didn’t go to Peacock!!!
Truly it is. Must be Alarr’s fault.
Peacock IS NBC!!! Don’t you remember the colorful Peacock that they use to show, everything I show started on channel 3, which was NBC in Nevada anyway. How people can think that Peacock ruined Days of Our Lives are wrong! The show would have been the same either way. Which is not as bad as people are saying! If you don’t like it, then STOP watching it instead of complaining about it!!!!
It stinks
I am shocked but not shocked at the same time, given what was happening on that set during this time. I think it’s shameful they wanted twelve-weeks and she told them she could not, so they told her they would do those twelve-weeks in a four-week timeframe. And then after two weeks & one day, they told her⏤at her request⏤ they would continue the ten additional weeks without her, despite telling everyone she would do doing the filming within a four-week period of time. It’s insanely unprofessional, especially given she was willing and able to put the time in, and they did not even give her a fair fighting chance.
They likely knew they’d be replacing her whether she returned or not, and we do know (via spoilers) that Emily O’Brien will be finishing the ten additional weeks worth of material (wearing a blonde wig). I am incredibly disappointed in what’s been done. It was poorly handled to all involved.
“We do know via spoilers…”
I’ve seen the spoilers you are referring to, and I’ve only seen them in one place, which is notorious for making up random dragonshit rumors about 99.9% of the time. And if you are familiar with that site, you have probably seen me over there throwing their dumb rumors right back at them.
In either case, ANY recast of Theresa, halfway through a short run, would be ridiculous. Swapping her out for Gwen would be 666 times more so. Sadly not unprecedented though, given the fairly recent example where they wrote out Serial Killer Ben and the next day, brought in Justin Kiriakis’s long lost son, who looked exactly like him. And then proceded to make “Alex” a cartoon character, just so nobody could confuse him with Ben.
Not surprised to read this was Alarr’s doing. Given Days 6 months ahead taping schedule, Hell only knows how many more ways he’s already damaged the show, that we have yet to experience before the shows made without him make it to the screen next January.
I totally agree with you Scott!
They should have kept her I’m the role
Jen is the one and only Theresa !!!!
I agree she is devil hardy harthat she is in a good way!! Jen is the one&ONLY Theresa Donavan!<-right?
I’m not offended at all that you compared Theresa to me, but Jen Lilley might be, as her religious beliefs are well known.
Bad move to recast Jen Lilley!!!!!! Especially when it’s going to be Gwen!!!!!!!
Agree on that
I cannot and will not think of Gwen as Theresa. Uck
I’m not or have ever been a Theresa fan after she tried to kill John – 3 times- and ran Melanie out of town. If it hadn’t been for Melanie,there would be no Tate. Fine way to thank Melanie.
Not cool! There is no one that can replace Jen as Theresa!
Seems like a pretty sh*tty thing to do. Was this just another one of AA’s rotten deeds? One has to wonder.
Still, I’m glad Jen will be back for a while and I hope people are kind to the recast, as it’s not her fault this is happening.
So – Jen comes up with the idea of Theresa coming back, says she can work 4 wks and she’s told the writers came up with 12 wks of material? What? If you weren’t planning on it to begin with, and the actor brings the idea up – how do you hear they are available for 4 wks so lets write 12 wks of story – that just a short while ago, you didn’t even have in the first place?? So stupid in planning and execution.
Jen Lilley brought the idea up to bring Theresa back and never gave a timeline. In response to her idea, they said they had a twelve-week run available and, she told them (via her agent), she was only available for three weeks, given her home life and other obligations. So, she wrote her agent an email to forward to TPTB at Days of Our Lives detailing that she did not want them to recast Theresa, and was willing to come in for four weeks to film whatever they wanted for that time. In response, they decided to bring her in for those four weeks and film the twelve weeks worth of material they said they had. According to Lilley’s telling of the situation, she never outlined how long she would be available when she presented the offer of bringing Theresa back; they assumed it’d be an extended stay like she’s done prior, and then claimed to have twelve weeks worth of material completely done involving Theresa.
After watching Days since the begining, it still disappoints that NBC moved it to Peacock where one needs to PAY to watch it. I have not been able to watch since
It’s the name of the game, unfortunately. Streaming *is* the future of media.
Disgusted hearing this!
Nobody better at playing that role than Jen Lilley…NOBODY! Get your heads out of your rear Days, KEEP JEN!!! The story of Theresa and Brady needs
to have them end up together somehow, and it needs to be Jen Lilley.
I liked Jen Lilly! She should be the one staying.
Keep Jen Lilley As Theresa’s. The shows needs someone like her to make the show more interesting.
Its been getting nothing new, same old thing, people getting a little bored of same story lines,
lasting forever like the devil storyline
I love this Teresa!!! Keep her
Not cool, bad way to treat such a loyal talent. Boo to Alarr
I think it was an unfortunate idea to recast the roll of Theresa with an actress currently on the show – it does not appear to be working.
Days Of Our Lives
‘Days of Our Lives’ Exec Explains How They Fit John Oliver’s Guest Stint into Production When They Tape Almost a Year in Advance

If you caught today’s Tuesday, August 11 episode of Days of Our Lives streaming on Peacock, you caught the debut of John Oliver in his Salem role as the chief water inspector in town named Devlin St. John.
The ‘Last Week Tonight’ host has been on a jaunt through the soaps over the past few months, first on General Hospital, where he played the WSB head named Z, to now the man who has got the goods on EJ DiMera.
In his first of three appearances (the remaining two stream August 12 and 14), Devlin meets up with Paulina Price (Jackée Harry), Julie Williams (Susan Seaforth Hayes), Rita Lesley (who takes a liking to Mr. St. Jonn), played by Maggie Carney, and EJ DiMera (Dan Feuerriegel). When Oliver arrives on the scene there is the wig, the quipping dialog, and a few soap stares and such along the way.

Courtesy/Peacock
Days of Our Lives is the only American soap opera in production to tape so far advance, often 10 to 11 months, that it makes it difficult to get out of any storyline that is not clicking with the fans, or if the writers want to change course.
In addition, casting announcement of exciting returns or new characters while initially exciting, finds the viewers having to wait a very long time to see them on their screens. On the flip side, without this production model the soap opera, which will turn 61 in November, wouldn’t remain and that would be a serious blow to the fans, to the soap genre and all that it employs.
DAYS OF OUR LIVES EP KEN CORDAY ON THE PROCESS OF ADDING JOHN OLIVER INTO PREVIOUSLY TAPED EPISODES
When John Oliver made his pronouncement on his late night talk show back in March that he desired to be on a soap opera. DAYS executive producer, Ken Corday was going to make it happen. He explained to Vulture, how they were able weave in Oliver’s request and take him up on it, while making it look seamless into episodes taped so long ago.
Both Corday and co-executive producer and showrunner, Noel Maxam, intially went back and looked at previously taped episodes and story outlines to search for a potential story thread where they could place the character to be played by Oliver.
Corday shared, “We didn’t want to wait until next year for these shows to air, so we lifted (already produced) show and put him in. We basically had to shoehorn him into our schedule because we were so far ahead.” The longtime EP also expressed its challenges stating it, “was somewhat complex. It was basically, ‘We have to do this; let’s get it done.’ And we did. He was too good to pass up.”
THE CREATION OF DEVLIN ST. JOHN
In terms of the scripting and creation of Oliver’s character of Devlin St. John, it was a two-team effort. Corday explained that Oliver’s overall storyline was scripted by DAYS writers, but John Oliver’s team punched up some of the dialog.
“John and his producer had a lot of input in making the words fit the way he talks,” the EP recalled. “He’s (Oliver) very machine-gun in how he speaks, so that took a little work. But in the end, we both got what we wanted.”
In terms of the look of his DAYS character of the Salem chief water inspector, Oliver brought the wig he wears in his scenes to the set, and the DAYS hair and make-up team refined it for the cameras.
You can check out more behind the scenes moments of Oliver’s appearance on Days of Our Lives in the newly released video package from Access Hollywood that dropped last night below.
So, what did you think of John Oliver’s debut as Devlin St. John on today’s Days of Our Lives? Ken Corday sharing how the soap opera was able to shoehorn in Oliver’s scenes in previous shot episodes from months ago? Weigh-in via the comment section below.
Days Of Our Lives
‘Last Week Tonight’ Host John Oliver’s Role on ‘Days of Our Lives’ Revealed

After a few months of speculation, it has finally been revealed who John Oliver will be playing when he kicks-off his three episode guest stint on Tuesday, August 11 on Peacock’s Days of Our Lives.
According to a rep for the soap opera, Oliver will be taking on the role of Salem’s Chief Water Inspector who opens an investigation into the local water supply. As previously reported, Oliver will share scenes with EJ (Dan Feuerriegel) and Rita (Maggie Carney), and Mayor Paulina Price (Jackée Harry).
In addition, Soaps.com spoke with Dan Feuerriegel who shared that Oliver’s character name is none other than “Devlin St. John.” Feuerriegel also explained what the late night talk show wanted out of his Days of Our Lives experience noting, “He wanted the whole thing. From my recollection, he wanted a wig. He wanted a ridiculous name, and he wanted to slap or be slapped.” Feuerriegel then coyly admitted, “We did all the things. Everything you would think cliché in a soap, we did. I got slapped. I slapped.”
Jackée Harry previewed her scenes with Oliver to TV Insider, noting, “He is the water commissioner and coming to her with some scheme. He is trying to get one over on the city of Salem and she is not having it. And then he’s onto the next victim.”

Photo: Peacock
JOHN OLIVER’S TOUR OF SOAP DUTY CONCLUDES IN SALEM
After his initial entrance on Tuesday, look for Oliver on the Wednesday, August 12 and Friday, August 14 of the soap streamer. Last month, John Oliver appeared on General Hospital in the role of the head of the WSB named Z for three episodes, as well which was more of a dramatic turn for the late night talk show host.
DAYS and GH both came calling after Oliver put the word out an episode of his HBO series back in March, that he is aiming to be on a soap! John shared, “To all the soap operas out there, let me say this: I’m officially offering myself to you. Write me a role, and I will be on your set so fast, it will make your head spin!”
Days of Our Lives executive producer, Ken Corday previously said in a statement, “When John Oliver said, ‘Call me, soaps, I’m available and willing to travel. I want to be a part of that world,’ our world, we had to heed the call!”
So, looking forward to tuning-in to see John Oliver as Salem’s Chief Water Inspector, Devlin St. John on this week on Days of Our Lives? Let us know via the comment section. But first, in case you missed it, check out this week’s Days of Our Lives promo below with Oliver as Devlin St. John asking to see Mayor Paulina Price in its final moments.
Days Of Our Lives
John Oliver Arrives on ‘Days of Our Lives’ in Mystery Role

Late Week Tonight host, John Oliver finishes up his tour of soap opera duty, next week in all-new episodes of Days of Our Lives. As previously reported, Oliver is arriving in Salem in a mystery role, but will share scenes with EJ (Dan Feuerriegel) and Rita (Maggie Carney), and from the newly-released Peacock promo with Mayor Paulina Price (Jackée Harry), too!
DAYS fans and ‘Late Night’ fans can look forward to three episodes featuring Oliver. First up on Tuesday, August 11, followed by Wednesday, August 12 and his last appearance on Friday, August 14.
Once Oliver put out the word on an episode of his HBO series back in March, sharing. “To all the soap operas out there, let me say this: I’m officially offering myself to you. Write me a role, and I will be on your set so fast, it will make your head spin,’ both General Hospital and Days of Our Lives came calling.

Photo: CordayProductionsInc
Oliver wrapped his three-episode General Hospital stint as the head of the WSB (World Security Bureau) on-screen on July 6, after his sudden emergence onto the scene of a shoutout and making quite the entrance via getting out of an actual helicopter on the July 2 episode. Oliver was praised by the GH cast and its fans for his portrayal as it was dramatic with a few soap tropes thrown in for fun, during his visit, too.
Now, can he do it again on Days of Our Lives? This time as of this posting, DAYS has not revealed who Oliver actually isportraying within the story, but we do know he is wearing a dark wig on his head. However, according to Soaps.com per Dan Feuerriegel, Oliver’s character’s name is “Devlin St. John.”
Days of Our Lives executive producer, Ken Corday previously said in a statement, “When John Oliver said, ‘Call me, soaps, I’m available and willing to travel. I want to be a part of that world,’ our world, we had to heed the call!”
As reported, Access Hollywood was on the set the day Oliver was in Salem and spoke to the guest star plus his scenes partner, Dan Feuerriegel and Maggie Carney, where Carney said of John, “He is fast, of course, quick on his feet. He definitely likes to improvise — which I do, too — but within the scope of the scene. So that’s so much fun. He’s very present.”
Now below, you can check out the promo sighting of John Oliver at the end of the teaser, while earlier in the video spoiler: Theo (Tyler Joseph Andrews) threatens Rita saying, “If you don’t get out of my way, I will make you get out of my way.” Stephanie (Abigail Klein) does not likeAlex’s (Robert Scott Wilson) plan to move into Joy’s (AlexAnn Hopkins) room at the pub. Rafe (Galen Gering) shows up and reveals he has been following Dimitri (Peter Porte) and it appears Chanel (Raven Bowens) is going into labor, or, is she? And did Theo get to say goodbye to his mother, Lexie (Nikki Crawford) in time? Stay tuned.
So, who exactly do you think John Oliver is playing next week when he arrives on Days of Our Lives? Intrigued to see how it all plays out after his successful stint as GH’s Z? Let us know via the comment section below.
-

General Hospital6 days agoChris McKenna Reportedly Out as ‘General Hospital’s’ Jack Brennan
-

News1 week agoLucas Adams and Tamara Braun Written Out of The Young and the Restless
-

General Hospital4 days ago‘General Hospital’ Alum, Chad Duell Releases New Music Track, ‘Static in the Quiet Room’
-

All My Children6 days ago‘All My Children’ Movie Writers for Lifetime Revealed: Ron Carlivati, Jamey Giddens and Leo Richardson
-

General Hospital6 days agoRyan Paevey Open to Return to ‘General Hospital’ to ‘Stir the Pot if Cassius Could be a Good Agent of Chaos’
-

All My Children7 days ago‘All My Children’ Revival Updates: Lifetime EVP Speaks on Why Proposed Movies are Great Fit, Mark Consuelos Wants To ‘Give Back’ to Fans
-

News2 days agoB&B’s Crew Morrow Featured in Courtroom Thriller ‘Wildcards’ Set for Theatrical Release and Tour
-

General Hospital1 week ago‘General Hospital’ Fan Club Weekend 2026 (Photos)
















