Breaking News
Michael Fairman TV Names The Best and Worst in Soaps 2022

134
Michael! I don’t post often but I look forward to this feature every year. Thanks for your work on this site. Can’t wait to read your picks and hear others’ reactions!
Gr8 compilation!!!
Wow, what a list! Thanks for all the time and effort it took to compile this “Best & Worst” collection. But, you forgot one category: Best Online Soap Opera News Source 2022? Michael Fairman!
I’m probably not in the majority on this but I find Nicholas Alexander Chavez WAY over the top when he’s upset; it’s so theatrical I feel like I’m watching Macbeth, lol. “Spencer” just gets on my last nerve. His animosity toward Ava is absurd; the stalking because she disappointed his 10-year-old-self? The whole hatred thing made no sense. Do I think he’s a good, older, recast? Yes; he’s great-looking and he fits the role for Spencer at this time in Spencer’s life…when he’s not playing Spencer as this tragic victim shouting his angst to the world, I enjoy the actor.
I agree. He’s overrated.
Agreed!
I completely agree with you regarding the over the top performances of Chavez. He definitely has had his moments but I often find him unwatchable♀️
I totally agree with this. Well said.
I agree, watching his character interact with the character of Trinia is like watching a really bad Hallmark movie.
I really loved the original Trina and her chemistry with Spencer…The new Sprina just doesn’t work as well and I find their height difference somewhat awkward.
I did as well, the original actress that played Trinia had chemistry via spades with Chavez. With the new version, its so forced and unnatural its just uncomfortable to watch.
Agreed. I fast forward through their scenes.
I disagree. Nicholas Chavez has brought an acting A game to GH since day one. He has done an amazing job with the material given him. And they changed his leading (Trina) lady on him with no break and he handled it like a pro!
I’m with you and Michael Fairman. As I see it, Mr. Chavez is most definitely NOT over the top. I realize that judging acting prowess can be subjective but I have no idea where folks are getting this impression. Chavez is understated when the scene calls for it, and he says more with his eyes, expression and mannerisms than most actors do when shrieking their lines in order to emote. Here’s an example; Spencer is sitting on the stairs of the stable house looking down at his father who is trying to wax euphoric about how much he loves his… Read more »
As usual, I agree with all your points, Harry. Rarely can an actor (much less one in his early 20s) display so many conflicting emotions in one scene. He’s fascinating to watch, and unpredictable. I love NOT knowing what he’ll do next. Unlike Dante, Droop, Finn, Cody, Michael, and others who’ve worn out their limited talents ages ago and offer nothing fresh.
Agree!!!
I like his acting. Maybe it’s because I am over the top when I’m upset.
Don’t forget Donald May (Adam Drake of Edge of Night and Kathryn Hayes Kim Hughes of As the World Turns fame
I did not forget – I simply highlighted the more tragic deaths. Thank you for your comment.
I read the list, and I noticed that you didn’t mention the Tessa and Mariah nuptials on Y&R, For me I think that wedding was the only bright spot on the show in 2022.
Kathryn Hayes death really upset me since ATWT was my favorite show.
You are so correct about Y&R. Bill Bell should be rolling over in his grave as this magnificent show (through 2005 specifically) has suffered so much through poor writing choices (some of these writers have had some good moments, even the awfulness that was Lynn Marie Latham and 2007). But I have never seen such boring, limp writing like I have under Josh Griffith. Stories are started and then dropped; there is a total aversion to drama. Such talented actors are given drivel for dialogue. It is hands down the worst it has ever been. TPTB are just as much… Read more »
Amen! I just can’t believe how CBS doesn’t step in and make a change to the writing team.
Joel, They also do not need the head writer be the executive producer at the same time. Only Bill Bell could do that. I fear now that JG is the sole runner of the show that the show will only fall in creativity. I mean how many “who is the daddy” storylines does one need… it’s been done and done and done. I could care less because Sally is shoved down the viewer’s throats every day. That’s another massive problem. Character development is so poor and uneven that many of the characters just do not work (like Sally and Elena).… Read more »
I disagree. I don’t care for Elana, but I LOVE Sally! She is intelligent, a hard worker and a great character.
She is definitely, the new Phyllis, she knocks me out.
Hope you arent comparing Sally to Phyllis. There is no one like that bitch that rains hell down on everyone in her atmosphere, even family.
Do not care for Sally
I have no idea why Josh is stlll at the helm at all. I would even welcome Jill Farren Phelps back to bring back some energy. Josh needs to go now.
The same w/ B & B. Sad to say.
I only watch General Hospital and although I’m slightly behind, I agree with your assessment.
Nice report. I don’t know what’s keeping B&B on the air. The writing? – Yikes! Thank goodness “The Bay” is on Peacock now & I’m searching for other online soaps.
B & B is a half hour soap and I think that’s helping it. Glad you mentioned the Bay because it’s overlooked and there are almost 100 episodes . Lots of current and former daytime actors in the cast.
Great list! Why is the press so afraid to call out the bad writing for Finn on GH though? The fans have been than vocal about it.
Just for Finn?
how about bad writing for characters not named Sonny, Carly, Nina and Britt.
someone should also explain to Frank and writing team what ensemble means.
The fans definitely have that covered! Finn became so unlikeable…he has an anger issue too.
Yes, the writing for Finn has been poor. I like Michael Easton, he deserves better. How about bringing him into this century with a new haircut and shave, too? If the romance with Liz doesn’t pan out, bring someone else in. Also, every pairing doesn’t have to revolve around a monster. There’s enough evil on the evening news. More love in the afternoon. More Vanna!
Michael Easton definitely deserves better. Plus, Finn and Liz have little to no chemistry; that pairing was terrible from the start.
NolaGirl
Actually I preferred him as Silas Clay and I’ve never seen Liz have chemistry with any man only sex.
Michael, you nailed it. I don’t watch Days but agree with everything you wrote about the other three. Thank You and Have a Happy New Year.
Days is doing a disservice to the talent that is Billy Flynn by keeping him in this stupid story. Do what needs to be done and bring Abigail back – there are thousands of capable actresses who would be willing to commit full time to that role – and put him back where he should be front and centre. This very clearly chabby wannabe triangle is not working.
Agree! And, the HW is a waste of time/talent. Bring Abby back (Marci or someone else). Marci is/was the best.
What is the HW?
Y&R is a complete disaster. The entire writing team needs to be replaced. On B&B, Sheila makes the show!
here are others who need screen time than Sheila. They are stuck on stupid.
Only being a GH viewer I can agree totally on your picks. “The best doofus” is perfection. Changing characters’ personalities is not new on GH but they really gutted Nikolas. Thanks!
Does anyone else think the actor who was playing Nicholas looks way too young. Even his physicality is off. Spencer towers over him. I never understood this casting
I just think he’s a bad actor. Maura, Genie and Nicholas all have to carry his weight when in scenes with him.
Yes, I agree. MC as Nikolas is no match for MW’s Ava.
Congrats have a great year ! Thank you for being honest the soaps we have four left they are awful
Unlike 2021, I agree with a lot of what this list has, especially Maura West’s entry and the feelings on General Hospital! Amazing list! But, my question to you, Mr Fairman: what do YOU think American soaps need to do to better themselves in 2023, especially when I do feel like we’re regressing in story-telling.
Love the praising for Finola Hughes’ work. She does so much in her scenes. Also agree with Anna and Valentin being picked as Best Couple of 2022. HANDS DOWN
Vanna is amazing. Shows that sexy isn’t just about skin and constant bedtime scenes. FH and JPS have really given this couple humanity with sensuality. Flaws included.
You forgot John Aniston. Smh
I did not forget John Aniston – i spotlighted the more tragic deaths in the daytime community this year.
Ok,sorry. I guess I misunderstood.
Gina, I do agree with you, sadly, a death is a death, is it not?
It was probably tragic for his family and friends. How about a compilation of every soap related person we lost in 2022. There were a bunch.
Folks, please look up the word,”tragic.” Dying of old age is really sad, it’s a loss for sure, but it’s not tragic- it’s natural.
michael great job and yes yes yes days is the most entertaining soap
and also michael great job on the shock of bold and the disappointment of young and restless and not only does gh need balance it is the most overrated soap on the air
Don’t think so. Watch B and B Y ad R. General Hospital is the best.
Correct the ERROR DOOL, BIG mistake to get rid of the Character Abby. Bring Marci back not matter what or recast her. Marci please come home.
I agree. I’m not a big Abby fan, but she should not have been killed off. Really bad decision!
Jeanine
More importantly was the way they killed her off, could it have been any more gorey?
agree fully!
Most Boring Story = Jacksonville Carly: Eat, Pray, Love. What a waste of time and money they spent to push this failed romance with Ryan Lavery. Anna and Valentin should’ve gotten the beach instead. Nobody asked for another rehashing of Carly’s childhood and the Reese retcons made it even worse. Carly doesn’t work as a crusader for the little people or in a relationship with an altar boy. And of course she went right back to scheming to keep Nina from knowing Willow is her daughter just like she did with Nelle. Kill off Austin. Bring back Todd. Carly’s last… Read more »
I live in Jacksonville. I tried to look past the silliness of the whole story but i just could not do it. It was so bad!
I disagree. The worst thing on General Hospital & what kept it from being good this year, was putting Sonny with Nina. No chemistry at all. When Sonny & Carley are together, they exude chemistry. There is no better actor than Laura Wright. She and Maurice Bernard have always been fabulous together. Would love to see Carley run Nina out of town.
Martha Anderson
Sorry, I loved Laura Wright on GL but Carly makes her so unlikable, even though she is better with Sonny. I’d also like to see Nina take a hike, it’s hard to even look at her.
But Linda Purl was excellent
Eat Pray Love is the perfect description of the Carly in Jacksonville detour!
It’s not the first time FV gave a Rebecca Herbst story to his OLTL faves. Tom Baker’s return was all about Franco trying to conquer his demons instead of Liz confronting her rapist 20 years later. Who cares about Finn’s late wife? Jeff Webber’s return after 40 years was all about making a story for Finn and Liz’s highly unpopular romance. It should’ve been all about the father and daughter reunion. Finn was painful to watch on Friday in his constant staring at Liz from across the room. Bring back Ric Lansing for Liz Webber. He would love sticking it… Read more »
Personally I am sick of poor Elizabeth getting the short end of the stick. RH was brought back after she was fired and FV has not helped her at all. If you don’t want her with Finn fine then recast Nik or bring Lucky back (resurrect Lulu too). RH deserves so much better.
I have to disagree about Y&R. It’s trying to be a soap again instead of boring filler hour. Diane and Tucker’s returns have been a plus than a minus to give the Abbotts a real story. I also liked more than disliked on Ashland pulling several fast ones on the Newmans. He was finally written like the true villain we were promised. Sally has been a good addition to the show. New faces are needed when they have a purpose. Chelsea’s downward spiral was a great story. Happy to see familiar faces like Daniel and Danny back.
How about Beth Maitland. She’s fabulous. Loved her reunion with Danny. Would love her to have a viable love interest. Also I totally agree with you as I’m sure many others do about SC. JG has his pets and Sony needs to do better on oversight now that he appears to have complete control.
Thank you, Vicki, for mentioning wonderful Beth Maitland. She needs a major story. Why not have her write a book about the history of the Newman family, fictionalized, and perhaps discover some buried secret. That’d be fun. I’d also like her to befriend Adam. Jack is the only Abbott who pays attention to him (understandably) but Traci could be a good friend to him, as she was to Cane Ashby.
Spot on about Kelly Thiebaud!!
I only watch Y&R and agree with all of your Y&R choices. My all-time favourite actor and character = Peter Bergman/Jack – but this is probably the first time he’s driven me to distraction in this Diane roller coaster – which I hope will end soon. I am a big Jack/Phyllis fan, always wanted them back together and they were so close. He couldn’t forgive Phyllis for one thing but is now on the Diane bandwagon. I’ve never thought of my Jackie as a Doofus but the time has come. I am a new fan of Trevor St. John –… Read more »
I forgot to add – the one comment about Y&R that I did not agree with was the Ashland/Victoria sl. Loved Richard Burgi and was sorry to see him go due only to an oversight on his part. Robert Newman did grow on me (although I preferred Burgi). Regardless, I don’t agree that the sl was a failure – at least in the beginning. There was such chemistry between Victoria and Ashland when Burgi came on [not quite so much with Newman.] Victoria glowed, I’ve never seen her like this in any other relationship. What failed was the way they… Read more »
I agree about the opinion regarding parts of Y&R. It’s the only soap I watch though. The podcasts of Billy were horrible, snooze city! The Ashland Locke story was such a disappointment because once again, Victor Newman, got away with covering up what really happened. That gets tiring. But now Chelsea and Billy are putting me to sleep and Elena and Nate together are a snoozefest. I dread the storyline coming up with Mariah and Tessa. Why does Tessa talk like a 10 year old? I love Diane and Jack together, but I’m sure the writers will ruin that too.… Read more »
Absolutely agree with both you and Mr. Fairman. Trevor St. John is a gem. I love his droll sense of humor which reveals the insanity of these characters with whom we’ve become so accustomed. He delivers his line with a deadpan sense of humor which lifts the dialogue to a whole new level. Clearly, Eileen ( Ashley) loves working with him too.
Isn’t he great, Harry? Trevor is a breath of fresh air. I smile like a fool whenever he’s on and, yes, he’s brought Eileen’s performances back to life. What a difference between him and Diane the Downer…and now Kyle has developed the same downturned mouth as a permanent facial expression. Way to turn a handsome guy into a drag, Diane!
Diane leading Jack down the wrong track. Don’t like them in this Fiasco. Like Phyllis much better.
Totally agree on the Tanner Novlan praise! The Sheila holding Finn hostage arc helped to rejuvenated the Finn character, giving him an added depth and layer and illustrated one of Tanner Novlan’s finest work. He gave a gut-wrenching raw performance accompanying with range of emotions (displaying anguish, sadness, helplessness, determination powerfully). I am really hoping he earns his first Emmy nomination this year for those compelling and masterful scenes.
Agree, Tanner has great potential.
wow! your picks are dead on!
Totally disagree about Tanner Novlan. When the camera is on him he’s passable but when he’s in a group scene it’s like he doesn’t know what to do. And always sucking on that bottom lip. As to his character’s return fron the dead it’s what made me end my relationship with the series
I agree, John. He was better in those Insurance commercials.
I complete disagree with you, and SoapHound. Tanner has chemistry in spades with his co-stars, especially, in group scenes. Whether, it is with his adoptive mother, Li, or birth mother, Sheila, and especially with his love interest, Steffy. Also, with his, in-laws, Taylor and Ridge It is palpable. Also, we can also speak endlessly, to his fantastic rapport with child actors. I think not many actors can connect with child actors, as much Tanner is able to do so, which is evident in the Sinn family reunion scenes, as well, as the Christmas episode with Finn and Kelly. They seem… Read more »
John
Talk about sucking on their lip, someday Jack’s will get stuck or he’ll wind up with teeth marks if he doesn’t knock it off.
Ok. I think I know who the hook killer is on GH. Adam, Joss’ classmate at PCU. The scenes are always her shutting down him down for trying to be nice to her. But I just read Adam (Josh Benard, Sonny’s real life son) just had an accident rock climbing. He fell and broke his back. I was right about Esme being Ryan Chamberlain’s daughter. I’m confident about who the hook killer is!
Wow! I think you’re right! On Friday I thought the hook killer did Not look like a female and besides Esme is locked in a tower.
I’m sure they just use stunt people for those shots. I don’t see them using the real Hook every time they use them in a shot or scene.
Sorry, can’t see this kid being the Hook. What motives does he have, if any? I think Bernard just wants his son on board.
I am sorry, but I think DAYS is unwatchable. The writing team careens from ridiculous plot point to the next. There is zero character development, zero beats where they really play the history unless it’s for comedic effect (or he completely re-writes a character), and he over and over shows he has no interest in actually playing out real impacts of character’s actions and/or plotting a realistic resolution of a story. Paulina and Chanel got off for murder literally because of something Belle did off-screen; no apparent impact or real consequences for their characters. Jada had an abortion and it’s… Read more »
I agree with so much of this post about Days, especially your point about the absence of playing out real impacts of the actions of characters and plotting resolutions. It’s absurd that the charges against Chanel and Paulina were dropped b/c of some legal maneuvering Belle did offscreen. Ari Zucker is a fine actress and she deserves better than the ridiculous, trashy way Nicole is being written. Kristen is a godawful character who needs to be written off the show. (I wouldn’t miss the actress, but it’s certainly not her fault that the writing for the character has been so… Read more »
I only watch GH and I think Kathleen Gati is pure gold. I’m not sure what category she’d be in but she’s had gut-wrenching scenes with Kelly Thiebaud as well as hilarious situations with Anna as they threw axes and destroyed TV’s and typewriters. Again, she’s just an incredible niche performer.
She is the best! I do miss her dark hair though.
Linda Moeller
Yes, definitely! She’s great and the scenes following Britt’s death were so sad and understandable.
100% agree! The scenes with Britt and Austin are always the best. I often wonder how much of their scenes are ad-libbed. They just seem to really have fun together.
Great article! I am also impressed that you did not give best soap to any show. Because they did not deserve it. I have been watching gh for years and was disappointed they won best writing because it is a serious issue with the show. The dragging story lines are done too slow that the audience loses interest and no longer cares. They are in danger of doing this with sprina. One of the most popular couples. Soaps need to understand that this is a different time where content of a whole season can be watched in one weekend. They… Read more »
Michael, Your lips to Brad Bells ears on getting KKL a decent story and a non Ridge love interest. Having this syrupy friendship with Taylor works but this daily high fiving and loving one another is ridiculous.
Taylor and brooke * NO way for this real friendship.
southern lade
The revised friendship is too much and if it turns into more, that will be the end for me.
I was a devoted Y&R fan but left over 5 years ago due to frustration with slow moving stories & too many characters. I began watching Days & GH and LOVE them. Was disappointed Days went to streaming. At least I still have GH
I couldnt agree more about kristen Dimera the whole thing about the villain is you love to hate them I dont even love to hate her I just cant stand her she either needs to do something good for a change or be written out cause it’s not even interesting she is heartless and all she makes me feel is disgusted
Brady Black
Wish the other Brady felt as you do, she’s really tiresome.
Thank You, Michael, for this feature ~ and really, this entire site! I look forward to reading your posts every day and especially look forward to your Best and Worst each year. I don’t comment a whole lot even though I read all the stories you carry. Sometimes, I wish I could just hit a “Like” button because what I would write would be repetitive. I trust your reporting and thank you for it. Please keep it going in 2023!
You didn’t include KATHRYN HAYS as a terrible loss this past year? My all-time favorite daytime actress. O.K., my picks: BEST OVERALL SERIES: General Hospital. I agree with the criticisms but it is the most entertaining show and the one with the most episodes where I loved entire episodes this past year. BEST OVERALL PERFORMANCE BY AN ACTRESS: Maura West as Ava, General Hospital BEST PERFORMANCE BY AN ACTRESS IN A STORYLINE: Kirsten Storms as Maxie, General Hospital – Peter takes Maxie overseas and she tells him off when he points a gun at her right before he is killed!… Read more »
The category was “TRAGIC” deaths. Kathryn Hayes passing although very sad, was not like those we mentioned in the specific category.
Thank you for your list of picks for the categories and Happy New Year.
Yes. Kathryn Hayes lived a good long life, and who crossed over at age 87. That’s not tragic. But Richard, loved your list- well done. Thank you.
” Drum Roll ” not one iota; not one mere mention … @GH Laura Wright, Chad Duell, or Eden McCoy. NOT ONE! Maurice Benard got one honorable mention, back in February, when he seizures out with Nina. Indicative, of just HOW DONE , the audience is with the Corinthos family known as the sonny and carly show. They do not carry the show.
Damn it, Fairman. I wish I could think of something negative to say but you were on point every step of the way. Moreover, this piece was really well written as you crystallized performances so succinctly. Well done!
Totally agree
Young and the Restless ( most disappointed soap )and yet it has been # 1 for the umpteen years I guess they thought Give someone else a chance to be # 1
Loved what you wrote about the Bold and Beautiful. It was a fail all year long. I am a day one watcher and stopped watching because of the repeated stories and lines. On the stories bad/good you nailed it! I loved what you wrote about Brooke. Love the actress would love to see her in a story where she didn’t have to cry all the time.
I only watch GH and I agree with most of your picks. However, I disagree about Tabyana Ali. I can’t watch her, her voice is terrible and her acting is just ok. I hope they recast the character. Sydney was great in the role and I wish she was still in it. I’m glad Laura Wright was not mentioned, she is a fantastic actress, but her pairing with Drew is sooo boring! There is no chemistry there and it feels forced. Speaking of no chemistry, Finn and Liz are just not interesting, neither are Joss and Cam. Joss and Dex… Read more »
Sydney left very big shoes to fill, I agree Tabyana does not fill them
JP1
Agree with your comments plus I don’t like Sam and Dante, Nina and Sonny and didn’t like Maxi and R.H, would have loved seeing him and Britt. I like Dr.O and Scotty and have really lost interest in Anna and Valentin, seems forced between them.I don’t like Nickolas and Ava, guess I’m sick of them both. Also, I find Curtis and Portia boring to say the least.
I totally agree about Sam and Dante, forgot to include them. Is it me, or is Sam just a bore? It’s like she’s just going through the motions. I feel like I dislike more of the couples than I do like. It’s got to be the writing because most of the cast is very talented. I love Curtis but, you’re right, he’s boring with Portia.
GH has faltered on the Nicholas/Eliizabeth story and screwed up Roger as Austin but it is still by far the best written and entertaining soap.
Honestly I couldn’t agree with u more about the Young and The Restless. Anthony Morina finally was let go after 4 years of the most lazy lifeless soap I have seen. Why the hell is Josh Griffith still at the helm of the soap now as the sole showrunner? Get Wendy Riche to helm YR and give it the changes it needs. Josh has been here over four years and it’s time for him to retire. I totally agree about GH it really was kind of a bust. Dan OConner and Chris Van Etten need to exit stage right and… Read more »
Totally agree with all the GH choices except the new Trina!
You nailed it on the head with all 4! I just wish these soap operas didn’t drag every storyline out for 6 months to a year! Now Esme went over the cliff again! Give it up!!
Greg as Leo is great fun. For me, Days is the best soap.
Hi Michael…I thought of a new category…Most Irritating Female Characters……Carly, Steffy, and Victoria. Runnerup…Phyllis. I can even stomach Diane over them and that’s saying a lot. :)))
rose
Can I add Abby, Chelsea, Liz and Nina to your list?
Violet…Of course add them as your choices. They are fast forward for me as well. Except Nina, and I know I’m in the minority here:)))
Your choice for the Most Shocking Soap is actually the Best Soap. B&B is in most of your best acting categories and the plot changes have viewers tuning in each day to see where Brad and his writing team will go next. Agree that GH is actually the Best Soap when it focuses on a few key storylines. Still don’t see how DOOL is most entertaining but agree that Y&R is the worst. I tried to watch but have enjoyed B&B the most in 2022.
Breaking News
Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes OUT at ABC and ‘GMA3’
Breaking News
Shemar Moore Becomes a Dad for the First Time with Girlfriend Jesiree Dizon as They Welcome Their Baby Girl
Breaking News
Alec Baldwin to Face Involuntary Manslaughter Charges in ‘Rust’ Shooting of Halyna Hutchins
-
General HospitalJanuary 29, 2023
General Hospital Alum Annie Wersching Dead at 45
-
General HospitalJanuary 22, 2023
Kelly Thiebaud Opens Up on Her Exit from General Hospital, Taping Britt’s Tragic Death Scenes, and Parting Thoughts on Co-Stars
-
Days Of Our LivesJanuary 27, 2023
Chrishell Stause Makes a Return to Days of our Lives
-
NewsJanuary 25, 2023
Y&R’s Tracey Bregman Receives Replacement Daytime Emmy from Christian LeBlanc on ‘The Talk’
-
NewsJanuary 24, 2023
TODAY: Tracey Bregman Visits ‘The Talk’ to Discuss Her 40th Anniversary With Y&R; Standalone Episode Airs Tomorrow
-
Days Of Our LivesJanuary 27, 2023
Zach Tinker Joins the Cast of CBS ‘Fire Country’
-
All My ChildrenJanuary 26, 2023
NBC Celebrates Carol Burnett’s 90th Birthday with Retrospective Special Featuring Susan Lucci and More Celebrity Guests
-
Breaking NewsJanuary 27, 2023
Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes OUT at ABC and ‘GMA3’