Having won other competitions including XFACTOR and being a already professional entertainer, she should not be competing again. I also wonder about her age. Is she really 25? Seems much older to me.

She needs to go. For the reasons stated above and the fact that she thought she was bettse than everyone else during duets and left her partner high and dry. Then she defended her actions, she should not be here, at all. NOT NUTS FOR NUTSA

Nutsa is the best singer in this competition. Hands down!

I was shocked that she was their choice. I didn’t know about her previous wins however I think American Idol should be for Americans. Granted she can sing but I don’t think she was better than some of the ones sent home. I also think her provocative performances in the past episodes is another reason she wasn’t “voted”thru to the top 12.

Nutsa should win the whole thing. If the rules say she can enter the contest, then she should be able to win fair and square. But she won’t win….not in America.

She shouldn’t have been on the show

She shouldn’t have been allowed to compete in the first place….Winning X Factor Georgia and participating in The Voice Turkey should have prevented her from participating….that is not what AMERICAN Idol is about. Plus she is not a resident of the US!!

No, she needs to go on. Give someone else a chance.

No, there were 7 extremely talented Americans standing up there. Nutsa not only does not reside in America, but she’s already won a competition in her country. It is not fair to the people who actually live here and are looking for their shot. I’m honestly very angry they chose her. Not fair.

Truthfully, I honestly don’t think it would be fair to the rest of the competition due to the fact she’s already established and pretty much professional at this point in life. Even though, no discrimination against her (Nutsa), she clearly does have what it takes to go all the way. But one must ask themselves, is it really fair? It is really truly fair to the rest of the contestants and the hard work they put in just to participate and come this far when in fact the rest of the competitors are indeed true Americans? I believe this will… Read more »

She should not qualify for this competition at all. Not a citizen and already has won many other competitions. Not fair to others trying to win. Disqualify her

Is it in the American Idol rules to be a novice and as well as not winning other competitions? They were already aware she lives in another country. I feel should disqualify a contestant.

It’s AMERICAN Idol, hello?

#NutsforNutsa
#NutsaStar
#TeamNutsa

Nutsa is best vote for her

There were much better singers then Nutsa…she was acting like a showgirl not a singer…it is a singing competition. Totally disappointed in American Idol. Katy Perry is trying to save face for all her off color comments.

NUTSA is a fake and a fraud and HAD NO business being on American Idol – the shows name says it all. Disappointment in this seasons judges (lead by Katy Perry) to choose Nutsa. Bad call, as have many of her actions. The fact that such a terrible (not so much) team player made it into the Top 20 after her behavior alongside her “partner” performance AND with 19 other exceptional participants, escapes us. We’ve been watching this show every season since its first season and if Nutsa remains (and perhaps Katy Perry), you’ll lose a household of (8) viewers… Read more »

Olivia Soli waz a much better singer…she was the total package…and she plays the piano.and she sings like a bird…she should have been saved not Nutsa

I have been a long time American idol fan since the beginning but i always thought it was American idol I do not believe a person that resides outside of the US should be allowed in the competition. Hence the name American idol!!!!

Wrong choice! Paige had a stronger voice!

No. Nutsa should not have been able to compete at ALL. Her attitude is bad when the cameras aren’t rolling AND she is NOT an American! American voters said NO and that should stand!!!

I think Idol, and other comps, should be for newbies. If you have already competed in and/or won other competitions then you had your chance. I am also of the opinion that if the show has the word America in it then it should be an American based competitor. JMHO

The show is called American Idol. There are plenty of young , talented, deserving people in the contest that are looking for a first time chance to further their singing careers from America….apparently the show’s purpose has changed direction??

I said from the beginning that she should not be on American Idol if she is residing in another country and never originated from here.

I am a Canadian and as much as I have cheered for our Canadians, it’s called AMERICAN IDOL not WORLDWIDE IDOL.
Anyone who has won any of these such contests I agree should not be allowed…they are changing other things on the show this should be one of them!!
if contestants have won others there must be a reason their career hasn’t flourished.
But love the show .. Hubby and I have seen every year since year #1!!!!!!!!!!!

NOT NUTS FOR NUTSA!!! She should NOT be in the top 12

No…I see her more as a contestant for the Voice. She’s good though!

Absolutely not. She should not be here trying to win an amateur singing competition in this country when she is a professional in other countries. It’s clearly cheating and we try to show we want her gone and the judges save her. What the hell was that.

This is called American Idol and I dont think it is fair for someone to compete in other versions such as this anf then knock out someone who has competed fir the first time and is just as talented. Nutsa needs to go to Vegas and not American Idol. I think she needs to prive she is 25 or under!

No nutsa! The other contestants were much more deserving!!

Absolutely not don’t like nut-sa or Lucy love!

Love Nutsa

There is no limitation for American citizenship in the American Idol contract. There is a restriction for American residency AND/OR a work permit to work in the US. Nutsa was accepted for American Idol and should be able to compete like any other competitor.

No Nutsa should not be on American Idol It’s not right! It was not right for the judges to choose her end and if she wins I may never watch American Idol again!

She’s an amazing singer, but I thought the rules for America idol stated you must reside in the United States. I’m confused about that.

Nutsa should not have been picked. There were others that deserved a change and that had way better talent

I do believe American Idol should be for American citizens. Katy Perry always seems to want to give a green card to those from other countries. Especially when they are not the best performers. There were several people much more deserving of the judges 2 votes, based purely on performance.

Elijah would have made it into the top 20 if not for less talented, non Americans being pushed ahead. AMERICAN IDOL Should be for Americans.

I do not feel she should be able to continue. She’s already proven To be a professional she needs to be excluded. Give someone else a chance who otherwise wouldn’t have one.

I don’t think Nutsa should have been selected. I would never listen to anything she sings.

NO she shouldn’t have been allowed through judges should have picked someone who was not famous that’s what American idol was before the no names with talent to give them a chance . It’s really discerning they picked her someone else deserved that more

No, for many reasons. She has competed in other major competitions and has an unfair advantage over the other raw talent.

It’s called American idol for a reason. Contestants need to be from America.

Good decision , i’m glad she is there and can sing . one of the best for my opinion

That should never be a factor there are contestants who come from all over the world just to make it on America’s Got Tallent nothing was ever said about that. There was a contestant who was on American Idol from Canada and that was okay. It sounds very discriminating if you ask me.

I didn’t agree with either choice. Lucy didn’t have a smile on her face the entire night. They were all so good. The two picks will be voted out by america .

Yes!!! Nutsa was awesome!!!

Nutsa is a polished performer and clearly not American. She doesn’t deny she flew in from her country of Georgia for the audition. So why then is she even allowed to audition and compete, let alone get this far in the competition. She is not an amateur. Her having won other competitions puts her in a different category. I strongly oppose her inclusion in the top ten. America made there votes clear. She does not belong with American idol top 10.

Finalists Should reside in US & Lucy appeared to be very rude with responses to her being chosen several times.

SHOULD NOT BE IN THE COMPETITION AT ALL! NARCISSIST!!! NEITHER SHOULD LUCY LOVE. NOWHERE NEAR AS TALENTED AS OLIVIA, PAIGE, MICHAEL ETC. FIXED TOTALLY. DONE WITH AMERICAN IDOL!!

Feel US citizens should only be allowed.